Preliminary findings for new University of Washington research into youth sports across the state were released Nov. 19, painting a troubling picture of an activity that is supposed to help children grow stronger, build confidence and find community. According to those findings from the research conducted by the University of Washington Center for Leadership in Athletics, nearly two-thirds of families with children in organized sports worry about the cost.
The study, commissioned by the King County Play Equity Coalition and which included a survey of 1033 Washington parents, shows that four in 10 report that their child has experienced harmful treatment by an adult involved in sports. And among families with children playing travel or select sports, 60% reported harm or misconduct by adults. Parents reported the following:
- 29.9%: Their child was encouraged to keep playing despite injury or pain.
- 26.4%: An adult spoke to their child in a shaming manner.
- 19%: An adult disregarded their child’s safety or well-being.
- 17%: Their child was verbally threatened by an adult.
- 32% of youth with disabilities had experienced all four forms of harm.
The full UW report is expected in spring 2027.
A Q & A with a researcher
We asked Julie McCleery, co-director of the UW Center for Leadership in Athletics, to weigh in on some aspects of the UW survey’s preliminary findings:
Seattle’s Child (SC) In this survey, a high percent of parents reported harmful treatment by an adult. What is driving these numbers?
Julie McCleery: I think the primary issue is the premium that is placed on winning or competitive outcomes in the travel/select environment. The increased pressure to win creates a number of issues that could be potential causes of those elevated numbers.
First, competitive pressure creates a higher stress environment for kids and adults. When people are stressed, they have a harder time regulating their emotions, so we see more adults in these environments acting in ways they typically wouldn’t act, which includes yelling at and berating young people.
Second, I think in high pressure competitive environments, adults can sometimes make choices that prioritize winning over the health and safety of a player.
We need to look closely at why we are creating these high stakes, competitive environments for younger and younger children. For a young child, many select/travel programs are creating high stress when what’s needed for learning sports fundamentals is low-stakes, high repetition, fun games. So not only does the increased focus on competition and winning compromise learning and enjoying the sport but it also creates environments where kids are experiencing actual harm. None of this points to developing a love of sport and long-term engagement, which is what we would hope for.
SC: Nearly one-third of parents reported their children were encouraged to play through injury or pain. What does your research tell us about how children experience this pressure”
McCleery: This survey, and my research in general, does not study the impact of how children experience this pressure. However, research does tell us that 50% of youth sports injuries are overuse injuries, which means they are preventable and caused by putting too much load on young bodies. So there are clearly physical repercussions for this choice.
Because our country has adopted a very “professionalized” model of youth sports focused on winning and competition at early ages, we’re asking young people’s bodies to do things they aren’t physically ready to do. We also don’t always trust young people’s voices to tell the difference between soreness and pain. Instead of helping them discern that and learn to understand their bodies, sports culture often demands they ignore pain and discomfort and “toughen up.” This can have really dire consequences depending on the issue. For example, this is why the Lystedt law exists in Washington state: the law requires that someone with a head injury be taken out of a game and see a medical professional. We can’t risk someone with a brain injury being asked to play through it, so the decision gets taken out of a coach’s hands. This is one of the only examples of regulation of youth sports in our state.
SC: How can parents distinguish healthy encouragement from harmful coaching?
McCleery: One important note is that parents should not just look at the coaching; they should look at the whole program and its context. Having your 9 year old join a soccer program that plays a lot of tournaments, travels out of state, and is focused on winning means that program is more likely to be steeped in the kind of environmental pressures that lead to adults pressuring young people to play through injury. These kinds of pressures (as discussed above) aren’t actually good for long term athlete development, so I would tell parents to look for programs that understand the science of athletic and youth development and shape their approach accordingly.
At the coaching level, parents should look for coaches who have been trained in youth development and positive coaching. They should ask what trainings the program provides for coaches, especially since none are required by the state for non-school-based coaches. Parents should ask about background checks and SafeSport training. They should ask what injury prevention and injury response measures the program and coach are prepared for. For example, athletic trainers are required at most high school sporting events, but I have been to youth sports tournaments (non-school) with hundreds of young people and not so much as a first-aid kit or ice pack was to be found.
In terms of the distinction between healthy encouragement and harmful pushing, I would say that a good coach always errs on the side of believing an athlete about pain or injury but also spends time talking to young people about how to manage pain and soreness, how to listen to their bodies, and how to train appropriately to reduce injury risk. In an atmosphere where those conversations are had regularly, both coach and athlete can more readily make a decision about whether to stay in a game or sit out.
SC: What does the family income and access disparity noted in the preliminary findings mean for children who are being left out?
McCleery: I think that (youth sports being a privilege) is a reality that we, culturally, seem willing to accept. As cost and cost pressures have risen and more low-income families are driven out of sports, our society seems to have just accepted the privatization of the youth sports market place as a given. Even as our taxes subsidize the fields and gyms that for-profit providers use to run programs and tournaments, we see a continued divestment in public, recreational affordable options. I think many municipalities have ceded youth sports programs to outside providers rather than compete with them which means fewer low-cost programs. While there are many incredible nonprofit organizations running youth sports programming, we see fewer of those in more rural areas, and we see the ones in urban areas having to compete for field space with the more well-resourced providers. Further, we haven’t really seen philanthropy view this as a space for deep investment nor have we seen government officials interested in stepping in to address this widening gap.
SC: If you could change three things about youth sports in Washington tomorrow, what would they be?
McCleery: I would add coaches to the long list of adults working with young people who are required to be background checked and receive mandatory reporter training, and add on the requirement for basic physical and mental health safety training. (Important to note that these things are required for school sport coaches just not for those outside of schools)
I would dispel the myth that highly structured youth sports programs are required for young people under 12 to get the activity and fundamental sports skills they need to be great athletes and lifelong athletes, and urge investment in more community-based (municipally funded), low and no cost, fun, movement-based opportunities for all kids to access, ideally many of them delivered at schools where young people already are (no travel necessary).
I would make for-profit entities that use public, tax-payer funded fields and facilities adhere to some basic quality and safety standards and require for-profit reinvestment in Washington’s youth sports infrastructure instead of that money going to their investors. Those investments could go to things like creating a state-level body for monitoring and oversight and monitoring of necessary coach trainings and safety and quality standards.
SC: Why might children with disability be especially vulnerable to all four forms of harmful treatment measured in the survey and what protections are missing?
McCleery: Research on abuse in sports routinely shows that vulnerable populations experience higher rates of abuse. This is because abuse arises in situations where there is a power differential; this is also why rates are higher in select/travel sports – because coaches have more power in those settings to determine an athlete’s future path in sports.
The more vulnerable a population, the more they experience situations where those power imbalances are enacted. Our research actually aligns with national and international research showing that people with disabilities are approximately four times more likely to be victimized than people without disabilities. Some of the other reasons for this (as well as some of the missing protections) are – first, coaches and programs may not be well trained to adapt activities for the specific needs of young people with disabilities and may not understand the nature and extent of a young person’s limitations well enough to provide support; second, young people with disabilities are more dependent on the adults in the sports setting to create a supportive environment from communication, equipment, facility accessibility, game modifications, etc… this creates more power-based interactions that could lead to problematic behaviors.